Wednesday, 24 July 2013

Dr Amartya Sen : The argumentative Indian:

Dear All


Dr Amartya Sen has proved again to be an Argumentative Indian.  

You should read the sixteen essays written by Dr Sen on the historical and political landscape of India’s argumentative tradition, where, he concludes that arguments are vital for the success of India’s democracy and politics. { Ref Amartya Sen: Argumentative Indian: Writing  on Indian History, Culture and identity } May be it is for us to keep up this tradition that he made national headlines yesterday. The Nobel laureate was not only critical of Narendra Modi’s model of governance but also made public his non acceptance of Modi , even as  a Prime Ministerial candidate.

As a developmental economist of International acclaim  with a leftist lineage, Dr Sen has always had his own critics on evaluating development in an economy. There are two sets of developmental economists. The first ones mainly the capitalist class, looks into the general increase in money supply in the economy and the resultant availability of capital for growth. It is this lot which measures the data on infrastructure development, banking and other macroeconomic indicators ,while the economists of leftist linage- to which  Dr Sen belong to -focuses on  social sector development, mainly on education ,health , poverty, freedom, human rights  etc. When we  analyse and give a value judgement on how good a state’s economy has performed we will always have economists and politicians who cherry picks data and interprets them. Accordingly for the leftist economists, the Kerala model of development may be far better than a Gujarat Model.

The Kerala model which was claimed to have created an egalitarian society with universal education and health care proved to be a misnomer. While education did result in skill development, there was no capital available for utilization of the same resulting in unemployment and skill migration. The Kerala economic development model has only resulted in creation of a money order economy with a dearth of capital, entrepreneurship and policy not to mention of left wing trade unionism. In the health front too while leftists economists talks about well ness indices of  Kerala State, its tribal region of Attapadi recorded nearly fifty child deaths in this year due to malnutrition . On the other hand Gujarat Model which focussed on capital and investment resulted in better roads, power and other infrastructure facilities making it the fastest growing state with no power failures. It increased employment opportunities not only to people of the states but also resulted in migration to the state for employment. On the education and health care front Dr Sen is right on pointing figures at Gujarat, because quality and standards of its health and education delivery system is dismal and needs change. While public distribution system is better than other states, capital percolation in health care and education has created more hospitals, schools and colleges but with low quality doctors and teachers. Most of the capital flows in education has come from the private sector but they have not been able to attract the best talent. It is often heard that school teachers themselves does not have the requisite knowledge and skill with cases of senior students engaged in teaching their juniors.

In such a contradicting scenario we cannot portray a state to have achieved or not have achieved any form of universal growth but growth need to be evaluated in the context of the indices of under discussion. Cheery picking economic growth numbers will never give a clear picture but can only add to political rhetoric.

Well whether Dr Sen accepts Mr Modi or not is his choice but he indeed has thrown open a debate prelude to election and hence proved to be a responsible and argumentative Indian.

Sanyasi

Friday, 19 July 2013

An Open letter to Arnab Goswami:


Dear Sir,

I know that I am writing this letter to the most articulate journalist in India. I do respect you for your stupendous contribution in the national media and the activism and vigour you show in bursting the hypocrisy of the political class. I watch your News hour program in Times now and have been following your stellar performance in the media ever since your NDTV times. However off late in your debates, you does not seem to play the ringmasters role of bringing divergent opinions to the nation, but instead you yourself get into the ring, and give an impression of taking sides. This gives an image of you taking positions in a debate. I think the flavour of your program is in your ability to expose the politicians by your rhetoric, but that should not get into a state of sensationalism which I doubt is happening now in your program. Secondly excessive emotion that you exhibit be it anger or sarcasm, does not taste good. I have found you yelling at the participants of them being touchy, but on the contrary you seem to be touchy while you are put in a spot. In one of the debates I heard you  saying that you are a citizen of India and you have a right to say what you want. However it should be understood that being a national figure, your right to speak should not offend others. Your activism on issues related to matters which are  subjudice, needs to be handled with caution especially when you are anchoring a national debate participated by the best brains in the country .

 Media activism and investigative journalism has made a difference to Indian democracy making it more transparent, but media too has a line not to be crossed which needs to defined by law. In the  judgement dated 19th April 2010 ( Manu sharma v/s State of Delhi) , the division bench of the Supreme Court comprising Justice P Satashivam and Justice Swatenter Kumar observed , and I quote ‘’ Presumption of innocence of an accused is a legal presumption and should not be destroyed at the very threshold through the process of media trial and that too when the investigation is pending. In that event, it will be opposed to the very basic rule of law and would impinge upon the protection granted to an accused under Article 21". The learned judges also cautions that the  ‘’freedom of speech protected under Article 19 (1-a) of the constitution has to be carefully and cautiously used so as to avoid  interference to administration of justice and leading to undesirable results in matters subjudice before the court”

As Parliament elections are nearing the private media finds enough sentiments in their ‘’market’’ which can be capitalized by sensationalism. Be it scamgates or modi mania  for a nation frustrated by their politicians , any ringmaster , who throws a ring to the  political class and make them juggle is a matter of satisfaction. However this does not absolve the ringmaster from his role of not being a player by himself.

Sanyasi

Saturday, 6 July 2013

Living in relation: The Elderly way:


Hi,
A recent visit to attend a mass marriage ceremony of lonely and elderly men and women opened a Pandora’s box of thoughts. Men and women aged above 60 but lonely due to the death of a spouse or neglected by children met and choose their companions for a living in relationship for the rest of their life. No strings attached, no liability clauses, you can choose your companion and live forever. Some couples choose not to live under a roof but to only share moments of companionship while on travel or on spending quality time together.

The greatest social threat that we face today is that of the social security of an elderly parent when they are alone. Aging is made synonymous with withdrawal from life and we make our elders a dependent, redundant and feeble human entity in the house by trying to be pseudo shrvan kumars . We approach them with an attitude of a protectionist, giving a heavy dose of instruction the moment they step out of the house or by restricting them to do household work and just spend time by reading and watching TV.  Extra expression of concern on their health, talking carefully with them, taking too much precaution while leaving them alone will only make them weak and dependent and  delicate showpieces in the house.  Our excessive considerations could be out of love or to make them feel special and valuable, but such a singular attitude makes them weak, aged or incapable rather than of confident individuals.  

The legend of Shravan Kumar, the mythological dedicated son of blind parents has been a part of traditional Indian household. Parents cherish their sons to be like shravan kumars to take care of them in their ripe age. Thanks to this tradition still in India we do not find our aged parents languish in old age homes unlike the few hapless ones put to the mercy of the caretakers.  

 In India aging is more related to the cultural mindset. The moment one touches 60, the person is regarded old i.e. not capable of doing work, need retirement from professional life etc . Children and young alike are indoctrinated to give a helping hand to old people. Young child holding hand of a healthy 60 plus is a common image cherished in literature and in Indian cinema. Oldies are expected to spend rest of their life in religious functions or similar types of activities. They should be away from the vibrant social activities. They should take rest, live with their married children, tell stories to their grandchildren and restrain from   their day to day work.

However, this type of mindset is not put into practice in reality. Majority of the elderly living with their children does not live a gratifying life; many are the victims of harassment by their own children and many feel alienated in their relationship with married children while living together. Living jointly is relentlessly marred by the issues of adjustment in life style, feeling marginalized, secluded, and ineffective.    

This is the traditional mindset on old age. Nevertheless, a genre of elderly people who have lived an independent lifestyle and believes in ageing gracefully finds difficult in fitting themselves into such a conservative mindset. They do not believe in shravan kumars tradition and culture.  For them such a living is suffocating.  Self reliant and own space is what present time elderly look forward to and strive for that. Ageing gracefully with spouse or without spouse is what a seventy plus wants. With sufficient funds, own house, friend circle and exciting travelling plans fills the life of today’s generation oldies. They would like to be in touch with happenings and developments in society. This phase of life is looked upon has rejoicing thoroughly each moment of  life which hitherto did not happen  due  to the rush for livelihood and  family responsibilities . No wonder, throughout world, in comparison to young people who are largely down with depression and worries, oldies are the happiest lot.  Perhaps how to live a fulfilling life is realized only at this stage by today’s mankind.  

The new living in relationship models among single old citizens is a step in the right direction and I was feeling OLD among a set of YOUNG 60 plus couples romancing each other.

Long live cupid:
Sanyasi:

Friday, 21 June 2013

sanyasi: Sex and the City : Circa 1300 AD: My sojourn at Ko...

sanyasi: Sex and the City : Circa 1300 AD: My sojourn at Ko...:   Hello, A Visit to the Sun Temple at Konark, in Orissa brings in reminiscence of a past on how, life was celebrated by the elite cl...

Thursday, 20 June 2013

Sex and the City : Circa 1300 AD: My sojourn at Konark:


 
Hello,
A Visit to the Sun Temple at Konark, in Orissa brings in reminiscence of a past on how, life was celebrated by the elite class consisting of Kings and Priests among the kingdoms at Kalinga. As an amateur   with a   subaltern mind-set, when I went there on 16th June the hoary temple at Konark gave me glimpses of  lascivious life style of the elite well   depicted and preserved in the erotic sculptures set in  amorous postures .
Konark is only 65 kms from Bhupaneswar and on the coast of the Bay of Bengal near to the Major Port of Paradip. The Sun temple was built by King Narasimhadeva -1 of the Eastern Ganga dynasty of the 13th century and is a world heritage site. It  was built in the form of a chariot of Sun God  driven by seven horses and made of black granite stone facing the eastern coast. The architecture of the temple which is in the northern style is made so scientifically that whenever the sun passes the equinox,  the rays of the sun glitters the diamond placed on the forehead of the idol. (The idol today is in National museum Delhi and the diamond is in British museum at London). The polished black sandstone is fixed in the columns with cast iron which are still not rusted in spite of the saline atmosphere here. In order to create a counterweighing balance to the iron clad structure the temple was made with magnets installed on the top.  (It is said that these magnets deflected the compasses and hence the direction of the Dutch and Portuguese ships steaming off shore during the 17th century. Removal of the magnet by the British rulers from the super structure affected the equilibrium of it ,resulting in structural damages as seen today) It is beyond doubt that the builders of the temple in the 13th century had a firm idea on electro magnetism, metallurgy and astronomy.
The local belief here is that the son of Krishna from Jampavati , named Samba built the temple as a tribute to Arka (sun) , for saving him from leprosy. However there is no historical proof to this. According to another legend, based on the wish of the queen of Narasimhadeva-1, the King called the master crafter, Bisa Maharana of Kalinga and instructed him to design and construct the temple in 12 years’ time with 1200 artisans.- The stones were shipped through local barges from the Andhra region and physically lifted to the site of construction which was just on the shore. It is said that the sea water during tides rose up to the sanctum sanctorum and in one of the floods the temple was destroyed, not to mention of the ruins created due to the iconoclasm of the Muslim rulers of Eastern India.-  In the last day of the 12th year Bisa Maharana nd his artisans were unable to install  the superstructure with only a night left. The King visited the site and ordered Bisa Mahara to complete the work before sun rise or to face death. However Bisa Maharana’s  twelve year old son erected the structure at midnight and drowned in the sea the next day to give credit to his father and save him and his craft men from death .-This   legend is a testimony to the arrogance of the early Kings and Sultans who took credit and went with their names into the  annual of history at the cost of talented craftsmen of the period. A real food for thought for the subalterns.
The erotism in the sculpture gave me a feeling that the elite enjoyed a sedentary lifestyle. The devadasi system which was prevalent there, gave ample scope for sexual extravaganza as temple women married an invisible God to be only  used up by the priests and kings. The other argument which came from the locals here , was that,  after the Kalinga War fought by King Asoka , nearly one lakh and twenty thousand men died –which  was nearly the whole of the young male population - making an equally number of women with no avenues for sexual gratification, resulting in polyandry and lesbianism and other forms of sexual voyeurism. Being from a generation ,  grown up from the remnants of Victorian moralism and later Hinduism, we may find it  difficult to accept the argument that  ancient India imbibed an open sexual life, and  is likely to view  those sculptures as voyeurism or tutelages of a maniac king. Well that is an argument or a thought process, but the conclusion here is on the glorification and celebration of sexuality unlike the hypocrisy of today s generation. Within the garb of moralism we deny and negate any form of expressive physical love, be in sex education to children or display of public affection, we are always on the verge of moral policing whether it is the society or the state. It is quite ironical to conclude that this repressed society of us evolved from a free and expressive population who lived centuries ago……………………………………

ILLUSTRATION:

 
The eight spokes of the chariot wheel portrays various stages in life and the cycle of life and death. It also depicts the division of time into 360 degrees based on the ecliptic movement of the sun.
 
 
Lesbianism was widely prevalent and practiced among the temple dancers
 

 
Cast iron bars used for the construction. Preserved and not rusted even after 700 years.

 
The Temple under renovation.
 


Canine saliva was believed to be an antiseptic to treat venereal diseases by women.
 
Oral Sex was prevalent those times long before the west claiming to have taught us about it
 
Prostitute waiting for her client.
 love making in posture 69  (middle sculpture)
Proof of rampant polyandry  .
Some ancient version of ''women on top"'
Serpentine desires .
 
I was tired and resting after an ecstatic journey over a landscape of 13th century eastern India

Monday, 17 June 2013

Changing Electoral landscape


The exit of Nitish Kumar from the BJP after a successful electoral alliance of 17 years is a turning point in the Indian political scenario. When the BJP emerged as a political party capable enough to counter the congress, it was the regional parties which sided either with the congress or the BJP, creating a bipolar political balance in the name of UPA and NDA. Since then we have been seeing the rule of these power blocks for more than a decade.

The current development is likely to result in the formation of a third front of regional satraps leading to a tri polar electoral battle in the coming Lok sabha election. On one side this runs the risk of no group getting an absolute majority resulting in a weak government and governance. On the other side it is an opportunity for the people to select a single party. India’s political landscape is now filled left right and centre and this elections are going to be a watershed elections paving way to new experiments in democracy . Lot of debates on secularism, nationalism, corruption and regionalism. Which issue is going to tilt votes is yet to be seen

Sunday, 9 June 2013

''Modi'' fication' of the BJP

The “Modi”’fication of the Bharatiya Janata Party has finally began. Narendra Modi after being first inducted into the Poll Panel is now expected to be its chief campaigning for the BJP for the 2014 general election. The BJP national executive currently under session at Panaji is likely to make a declaration to this effect.

Narendra Modi and the modification of BJP has been a case of intense speculation since a year which attained momentum after the successful Gujarat assembly polls and lately after the sweep of the BJP in the Gujarat and after the change in the President ship of BJP from Nitin Gadkari to Rajnath Singh.

On one side it is an acknowledged fact that the BJP is in a major stage of leadership transition. It is similar to the transition of the BJP which we witnessed in the early 90s when L K Advani started the Rathyatra which resulted in the emergence of BJP as a national political party in India. In all such transition there is always a state of dissent and the resultant media speculation. If you recollect the 90s, when the baton was moving towards Mr Advani, there was speculation of an hard-line Advani camp and the Vajpayee camp. While the moderate Vajpayee camp disapproved of the hardliner’s Babari masjid campaign, the rest is history. The hard-liners  won the election under  Advani’s leadership, and BJP became the principal opposition party. Subsequently after the formation of the NDA, when the BJP came to power, the “ hardliner” Advani humbly paved way for the soft and acceptable leader AB Vajpayee to become the Prime Minister.

Today when a similar transition is being witnessed, will Mr Modi show the same audacity and humility to pave way for the veteran leader Mr Advani to be the Prime minister and he occupy the home minister’’s role? Well that is yet to be seen. However there is much debate on who should be the BJP’s Prime Ministerial candidate. Today in a media managed election campaign when Modi is at the helm of BJPs election needs’, an analysis is necessary, especially for my overseas readers, of what makes or unmakes Modi as far as far as the Prime Minister ship is concerned . As a general secretary and spokesman of BJP,  Modi in the early 90s was sent to his home state of Gujarat to counter the severe infighting, corruption and nepotism within the then BJP in Gujarat epitomized by the vagaries   of two leaders viz Keshubhai Patel and Shankar Singh waghela. The state of Gujarat was also traumatized after the killer quake of 2001 . There was enormous caste anarchy with the Patel community ruling the roast. It is into such a socially and politically turbulent atmosphere that Modi was sent. His background as an RSS pracharak in Gujarat had given him a strong insight of the social fabric and its sensitivities. Three months into his position, Gujarat saw the worst communal violence of the time predominantly a retaliation of the Hindu fundamentalists against the incidence of the Muslim radical’s attack on a train killing nearly 57 Hindu men and women. The uncontrolled and unabated violence left nearly 2000 people killed. The involvement of the BJP cadre led by local leaders , and the inability of Mr Modi to quell the violence – making Vajpayee warn him of following Raj Dharma or Statecraft – indeed resulted in the “”monstor-ification “’ of him as a fascist iconoclast and inimical to the essence of secularism and national unity. Well whether he followed Raj dharma or not is not the purview of this article, but since then Modi ruled Gujarat with a single point agenda of development of the economy and bringing up the Gujarati asmita or pride. His successful re -election and the development in investment and infrastructure thereafter and most importantly the connect of the common people with him increased his popularity as we stand today.

However this achievement does make him a PM candidate. Yes as well as No. The reason he is clamoured as a future PM is primarily due to the leadership crunch faced by a nation. He is a man who has proved to be a leader and thought about the nation and his State beyond his self Interest. He is astutely principled, non – corrupt and a strict disciplinarian. Moreover he is accessible to the common man sans his security needs. The nation requires a PM who is decisive and tough and a strong implementer unlike the current PM. While this makes him eligible what lacks in him is the pan national acceptability, shrouded image of a hardliner Hindu radical, above all inexperience in national level administration and statecraft. This can happen if he follows his mentor LK Advani, by winning an election and abdicating the desire to be a PM, and instead be a Home minister paving way for the nationally acclaimed patriarch LK Advani to be the PM only to be accepted later as a national leader later in life. What happens is yet to be seen, but wishing Narendrabhai all the best


Sanyasi